- Pruney
- Pryce
- Pryor
- Puckeridge
- Puddicombe
- Puddock
- George (between 1867 and 1868 - after 1897)
- Peter (1788 - 1867)
- Peter (1822 - circa 1902)
- Puddy
- Pugh
- Pugsley
- Pulford
- Pullen
- Pulling
- Pullinger
- Pulner
- Pumphrey
- Purcell
- Purdue
- Purdy
- Purkey
- Purkis
- Purnell
- Pursey
- Purton
- Purveur
- Purvey
- Purvis
- Purvure
- Putland
- Putley
- Putnam
- Puttick