- Shelton
- Shephard
- Shepherd
- Shepley
- Sheppard
- Shepperd
- Sherborne
- Sheriton
- Sherling
- Sherlock
- Sherman
- Sherrod
- Sherwin
- Sherwood
- Shetlin
- Shield
- Shields
- Shiffner
- Shill
- Shiner
- Shipley
- Shipman
- Shipway
- Shirley
- Shirt
- Shiska
- Shively
- Shoebridge
- Sarah (between 1803 and 1804 - circa 1879)
- Shoesmith
- Sholmatoff
- Shore
- Shorney
- Short
- Shorting
- Shortman
- Shoubridge
- Shoulders
- Shove